The Arnao Insurance Agency

Payments and Claims

Payment and claim information is available below for the insurance companies we represent. If you are having trouble reaching your insurance company or have questions, please feel free to contact us directly.
Agency Insurance
Agency Insurance Company

Billing: 800-492-5629

Claims: 800-841-5241

American Modern
American Modern Insurance

Billing: 800-453-2644

Claims: 800-375-2075

Chubb Insurance
CHUBB Insurance Company

Billing: 866-324-8222

Claims: 800-252-4670

Encompass Insurance
Encompass Insurance Company

Billing: 800-262-9262

Claims: 800-588-7400

Agency Insurance
Farmers Fire Insurance

Billing: 800-537-0928

Claims: 800-537-0928

Foremost Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group

Billing: 800-532-4221

Claims: 800-527-3907

Chubb Insurance
Grange Insurance

Billing: 800-422-0550

Claims: 800-445-3030

Encompass Insurance
Hagerty Insurance

Billing: 888-566-9701

Claims: 800-385-0274

Kemper Insurance Company
Kemper Insurance Company

Billing: 877-488-7499

Claims: 888-252-2799

American Modern
MetLife Insurance Company

Billing: 800-422-4272

Claims: 800-854-6011

Chubb Insurance
Nationwide Insurance

Billing: 877-669-6877

Claims: 800-421-3535

NGM Insurance Company
NGM Insurance Company

Billing: 800-207-0446

Claims: 877-425-2467

Agency Insurance
Progressive Insurance

Billing: 800-876-5581

Claims: 800-274-4499

American Modern
The Hartford Insurance

Billing: 866-467-8730

Claims: 800-327-3636

Chubb Insurance
Travelers Insurance

Billing: 800-842-5075

Claims: 800-252-4633

Encompass Insurance
Universal Property Insurance

Billing: 800-425-9113

Claims: 800-425-9113

Agency Insurance
Utica First Insurance Company

Billing: 800-456-4556

Claims: 800-456-4556 (option 7)

American Modern
Vacant Express Insurance

Billing: 800-310-3351

Claims: 800-310-3351

Westfield Insurance Company
Westfield Insurance

Billing: 800-552-9134

Claims: 866-937-2663


Get Started with Your Hometown Agency

Call the Arnao Agency at 610-489-1122, or fill out the form below today to get started on finding the right policy for you.

Contact Us:

379 E Main Street

Collegeville, PA 19426


Your Hometown Agency | Servicing Collegeville PA, Trappe PA, Royersford PA, Norristown PA, Limerick PA, Phoenixville PA and Surrounding Areas.

Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions